Money Metals Exchange Review (2026): Is This Idaho Dealer and Vault a Good Fit?
Looking for the best offer for a Gold IRA?
Get Free Gold IRA KitMoney Metals Exchange Review: Quick Verdict
Money Metals Exchange is a legitimate bullion dealer based in Eagle, Idaho. It was founded in 2010 by Stefan Gleason, its president and CEO, with his brother Mike Gleason and Clint Siegner. Its stated mission is selling bullion priced close to melt value rather than high-markup collector coins.
Its standout feature is Money Metals Depository, its own vault in Eagle, where metal is held in segregated storage. In 2025 it opened a 37,000-square-foot depository facility there.
It's a good fit for cash buyers who want their metal stored in a segregated vault. For IRAs, it works with a custodian (New Direction Trust Company). If you want one company to run a whole rollover, compare Augusta Precious Metals and Noble Gold.
On This Page
- Money Metals Exchange Review: Quick Verdict
- Money Metals Exchange Pros and Cons
- Money Metals History and Background
- Money Metals Prices and Payment
- Money Metals Depository and Storage Fees
- Money Metals Gold IRA
- Selling to Money Metals
- Taxes on Money Metals Purchases
- Money Metals Reputation
- Money Metals vs Other Dealers
- Who Is Money Metals Best For?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Sources
Money Metals Exchange Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Own depository with segregated storage | Dealer and vault owned by the same company |
| Focus on bullion priced near melt value | Card and PayPal payments cost more |
| Storage fees fall as a percentage on larger holdings | Percentage storage fees grow with your holdings |
| Monthly purchase program | Customers report slow intake of metal shipped in |
| Long-standing public advocacy on sound-money laws | IRA custodian options are limited |
Money Metals History and Background

Stefan Gleason started Money Metals Exchange in 2010, saying he wanted to offer an alternative to dealers who sold "rare" coins at very large markups. He runs the company with Mike Gleason and Clint Siegner, who are listed as directors. Gleason also leads the Sound Money Defense League, which campaigns for state sound-money laws, such as removing sales taxes on precious metals.
The company sells gold, silver, platinum, palladium, rhodium and copper. It also runs a monthly purchase program for buying metal on a schedule and offers loans backed by metal.
Money Metals Prices and Payment
Money Metals posts its prices online. Like other dealers, it charges more for card and PayPal payments; reviewers have reported a fee of about 4% for those methods. Paying by wire or check avoids it.
On common bullion, reviewers have found its prices close to other large online dealers'. As always, compare the same product, quantity and payment method across two or three dealers at the same moment. See the gold spot price explained for how to work out the premium you're paying.
Money Metals Depository and Storage Fees
Money Metals Depository holds customer metal in segregated storage, meaning your specific coins and bars are kept physically apart from other customers'. Reviewers report that it is insured and monitored around the clock. Its 37,000-square-foot facility in Eagle opened in 2025.
| Value Stored | Annual Storage Fee (as Reported) |
|---|---|
| Up to $15,999 | $96 a year |
| $16,000 to $99,999 | 0.59% a year |
| $100,000 to $999,999 | 0.49% a year |
| $1 million or more | 0.39% a year |
Tiers as reported by The Smart Investor. Confirm current fees with Money Metals.
Yearly Storage Cost at Money Metals Depository
Source: Reported Money Metals storage tiers
Percentage vs Flat Storage
A percentage fee is fair on small holdings but grows as your metal grows. At $250,000, 0.49% is $1,225 a year. Flat-fee storage is usually cheaper on large balances: Noble Gold, for example, includes segregated storage in a $275 flat annual IRA fee.
Dealer-Owned Storage
When the dealer also runs the vault, there's no independent party between your money and your metal. Many investors are fine with that; others prefer an independent depository such as the Delaware Depository, Brink's or International Depository Services. Ask for audit details. See our gold IRA depositories guide.
Money Metals Gold IRA

Money Metals isn't a custodian. For an IRA:
- Open a self-directed IRA with a custodian. Money Metals mainly works with New Direction Trust Company.
- Fund it by transfer or rollover.
- Buy IRA-eligible metal from Money Metals.
- Store it at Money Metals Depository or another approved depository.
New Direction charges its own fees, including a flat annual fee and a fee for each buy or sell. It's also a defendant in a pending class action over a different depository (allegations only). Read our New Direction Trust Company page before you open an account.
Ask About Augusta's Fee Coverage
Augusta says qualifying accounts may have custodian and storage fees paid for up to 10 years. Terms apply, so confirm them with Augusta.
Selling to Money Metals
Money Metals buys back bullion, including metal stored in its depository, which can make selling quicker because nothing has to be shipped. Get a quote, lock it, and payment follows. Compare its bid with other dealers'. See where to sell gold.
Taxes on Money Metals Purchases
- Sales tax may apply in some states. See sales tax on gold by state.
- Gains on physical metal outside an IRA are taxed as collectibles, at a top long-term federal rate of 28%.
- Metal stored in the depository is still yours for tax purposes; selling it is a taxable sale.
- Inside an IRA, trades aren't taxed until you take a distribution. See gold IRA tax rules.
Money Metals Reputation
Money Metals has strong ratings on major review sites, according to reviewers. Complaints we found included slow logging of metal customers shipped into the depository and shipping fees they didn't expect. We didn't find CFTC or SEC enforcement actions naming Money Metals.
Money Metals vs Other Dealers
| Money Metals | APMEX | JM Bullion | SD Bullion | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Based | Eagle, ID | Oklahoma City | Dallas | Texas |
| Founded | 2010 | 2000 | 2011 | 2012 |
| Own depository | Yes, segregated | No | No | Yes |
| IRA custodian partner | New Direction | Several | New Direction (preferred) | New Direction |
See our APMEX, JM Bullion and SD Bullion reviews.
Who Is Money Metals Best For?
- Cash buyers who want metal stored in a segregated vault
- Monthly savers using its purchase program
- Investors who like its sound-money advocacy
Who should look elsewhere? Retirement savers with large balances who want flat-fee storage and a full-service rollover. Augusta and Noble Gold handle the custodian, depository and paperwork for you.
Get Both Free Gold IRA Kits
Free, no-obligation information from our top two picks.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Money Metals Exchange Legit?
Yes. It's operated since 2010 from Eagle, Idaho, and we found no CFTC or SEC actions naming it.
Who Owns Money Metals Exchange?
It was founded by Stefan Gleason, its president and CEO, with Mike Gleason and Clint Siegner.
Is Money Metals Storage Segregated?
Yes. Its storage agreement says customer metal is held physically separate from other customers' assets.
How Much Is Money Metals Storage?
Reported tiers: $96 a year up to $15,999, then 0.59%, 0.49% and 0.39% as holdings grow.
Does Money Metals Offer Gold IRAs?
Yes, through a custodian partner, mainly New Direction Trust Company.
Sources
- Money Metals Depository: Storage agreement (segregated storage)
- Money Metals Insider, Summer 2026 (leadership)
- The Smart Investor: Money Metals Exchange review (storage tiers)
- Mugglehead: Money Metals opens 37,000 sq ft depository
- Finder: Money Metals Exchange review (card fee)
Moving Retirement Savings Into Gold?
Request the free information kits and compare them side by side. There is no cost or obligation.