Gold IRA Company Lawsuits, Fraud Cases and Failures (2026): What Regulators Found
Gold IRA Fraud: The Short Answer
Most gold IRA dealers are legitimate businesses. But over the past several years, federal and state regulators have brought some of their largest precious metals fraud cases against dealers that sold overpriced coins to retirees through self-directed IRAs. Several other dealers collapsed, leaving customers who had paid for metal that never arrived.
The cases follow a pattern. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), FINRA and the North American Securities Administrators Association (NASAA) have jointly warned retirees that fraudulent dealers push retirement rollovers because that's where most people keep their savings, then charge exorbitant markups, commissions and fees.
This page lists the major cases, using regulator and court records, and the warning signs they shared. Allegations are described as allegations unless a court entered a judgment or the parties settled.
Before You Trust Any Dealer, Read This
Augusta's free Buyer Beware guide covers common gold IRA dealer sales tactics and the questions that expose them.
On This Page
- Gold IRA Fraud: The Short Answer
- Major Regulator Cases Against Precious Metals Dealers
- Red Rock Secured: Markups Over 100%
- Safeguard Metals: $68 Million from Retirees
- Regal Assets: About $49 Million Ordered
- Metals.com: A $185 Million Case
- Lear Capital: Hidden Commissions
- Dealers That Collapsed
- Telemarketing Cases Are Different
- What Happens to Your Metal When a Dealer Fails?
- How to Check a Dealer's Record Yourself
- The Warning Signs These Cases Share
- How to Protect Yourself
- Why We Recommend Augusta and Noble Gold
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Sources
For the everyday schemes and red flags, see gold IRA scams and our breakdown of free silver offers.
Major Regulator Cases Against Precious Metals Dealers

| Dealer | Regulators | What was found or alleged | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Red Rock Secured | CFTC, California DFPI, Hawaii | Markups of about 100% to 130% on coins sold to retirees, while customers were told of far lower fees (Nov. 2019–Feb. 2022) | April 2024 consent order: $38.98M restitution, $5.1M disgorgement, $12.25M penalties |
| Safeguard Metals | CFTC and 30 states | About $68M taken from 450+ mostly elderly customers through overpriced coins | Liability consent order (2023); Sept. 2025 final judgment: $25.6M restitution and $25.6M penalty |
| Regal Assets | CFTC, California DFPI | Alleged misappropriation of customer funds | Oct. 2024 default judgments: about $21.9M restitution and $27.3M penalties |
| TMTE / Metals.com | CFTC and 30 states | Alleged $185M fraud targeting the elderly (filed 2020) | Receiver appointed; earlier Texas emergency cease-and-desist (2019) |
| First State Depository / Argent Asset Group | CFTC | Precious metals fraud | Consent order: $112.7M restitution, $33M penalty |
| Lear Capital | New York AG; multi-state regulators | Alleged hidden commissions up to 33% | $6M NY settlement (2022); $5.5M investor payout via bankruptcy plan (2023) |
Sources: CFTC press releases and court filings; New York Attorney General; Texas State Securities Board. See Sources below.
Red Rock Secured: Markups Over 100%
According to the CFTC's complaint, from at least November 2019 through February 2022, Red Rock Secured, its CEO and a senior salesperson persuaded customers, many elderly, to move retirement savings into precious metals IRAs. Customers were told of small fees, in some cases 1% to 5%, but Red Rock routinely charged markups of about 100% to 130% on the coins it recommended.
In April 2024, a federal judge in California entered a consent order requiring the defendants to pay about $39 million in restitution, disgorge $5.1 million and pay $12.25 million in civil penalties.
Safeguard Metals: $68 Million from Retirees
The CFTC and 30 state regulators sued Safeguard Metals and its owner in 2022. The defendants later consented to liability for a scheme that took in about $68 million from more than 450 mostly elderly or retirement-aged customers, who were persuaded to liquidate retirement accounts to buy overpriced silver coins.
In September 2025, the court entered a final judgment ordering $25.6 million in restitution and a $25.6 million civil penalty.
Regal Assets: About $49 Million Ordered
In October 2024, a federal judge entered default judgments against Regal Assets and related defendants for about $21.9 million in restitution and $27.3 million in penalties. See our full Regal Assets case summary.
Metals.com: A $185 Million Case
In September 2020, the CFTC and 30 states charged TMTE, Inc. (doing business as Metals.com), Chase Metals and Barrick Capital and their principals with an alleged $185 million fraud targeting the elderly, the largest joint filing between the CFTC and state regulators at the time. The court appointed a receiver. Texas had earlier entered an emergency cease-and-desist order in 2019, and Metals.com agreed to a rescission offer to 84 Texas investors expected to exceed $10 million.
Lear Capital: Hidden Commissions
New York's Attorney General alleged that Lear Capital charged hidden commissions of up to 33% to nearly 1,000 New Yorkers. Lear paid $6 million in January 2022, then paid $5.5 million to investors through its bankruptcy plan in 2023 and agreed to new sales-practice rules. Lear still operates. See our Lear Capital review.
Dealers That Collapsed

Not every loss comes from a regulator case. Some dealers simply failed, leaving customers who'd paid for undelivered metal as creditors:
| Dealer | What happened | When |
|---|---|---|
| Rosland Capital | Liquidating Chapter 11; filing showed no metals inventory and more than $60M owed to about 617 customers (as reported) | July 2026 |
| Oxford Gold Group | Customers filed an involuntary Chapter 7; complaints of undelivered IRA metals | August 2024 |
| Gold Alliance | Announced on its website that it was closing its business, effective June 24, 2024 | June 2024 |
Read our guides for Rosland Capital customers and Oxford Gold Group customers.
Telemarketing Cases Are Different
Some well-known companies have faced lawsuits over how they contacted people, not over metal prices. Goldco settled a $2 million class action over marketing texts, and a 2023 telemarketing suit against American Hartford Gold's operating company was closed in 2024. These cases are worth knowing about, but they're not fraud findings. See our Goldco lawsuit and American Hartford Gold pages.
What Happens to Your Metal When a Dealer Fails?
It depends on whether the metal was delivered:
| Situation | What usually happens |
|---|---|
| Metal delivered and recorded in your IRA at a depository | It belongs to your IRA, not the dealer. Your custodian can keep it, sell it or transfer it |
| You paid, but the metal was never bought or delivered | You're usually an unsecured creditor in the bankruptcy, with a claim for the money |
| You sold back to the dealer and weren't paid | Also a creditor claim |
This is why confirming delivery matters. A custodian statement showing specific coins at a named depository is your best protection.
How to Check a Dealer's Record Yourself
- CFTC: search press releases at cftc.gov for the company's name.
- SEC: search litigation releases and EDGAR at sec.gov.
- State regulators: check your state securities regulator and attorney general.
- Courts: search the company's legal name on CourtListener or PACER.
- BBB: read actual complaints and responses, not just the grade.
Search the legal entity name from your paperwork, not just the brand, because cases name the entity.
The Warning Signs These Cases Share
| Warning sign | Seen in |
|---|---|
| Pressure to move retirement savings into metals quickly | Red Rock, Safeguard, Metals.com |
| Fear-based pitches about banks, markets or the dollar | Multiple CFTC complaints |
| Quoted fees far lower than the real markup | Red Rock, Safeguard, Lear (alleged) |
| Proprietary, proof or "rare" coins instead of bullion | Red Rock, Safeguard |
| Paid but undelivered orders | Rosland, Oxford |
| Unanswered complaints and custodians cutting ties | Oxford |
How to Protect Yourself
- Get the markup in writing. Ask for the price per coin and the spot price at the same moment. Walk away if a dealer won't give it.
- Prefer bullion. IRA-eligible bullion coins and bars carry far lower premiums than proof or "exclusive" coins. See bullion vs numismatic coins.
- Choose your own custodian if you can, and confirm the account with the custodian directly.
- Check delivery. Your custodian's statement should show the metal soon after you pay.
- Search the records. Look up the dealer's legal name on cftc.gov, sec.gov, your state regulator and CourtListener.
- Never act on an unsolicited call. Especially one offering to "rescue" an account at a failed dealer.
Comparing Companies? Use a Checklist
Augusta's free checklist lists the questions to ask any gold IRA dealer before you sign.
Why We Recommend Augusta and Noble Gold
Neither of our top two picks appears in the regulator cases above, and both publish their account fees. Augusta Precious Metals says it doesn't offer free-silver promotions, documents its buyback process and works through independent custodians and depositories. Noble Gold publishes a flat fee that includes segregated storage at International Depository Services. Still, apply every step above to them too.
Rolling Over $50,000 or More?
Augusta Precious Metals is our #1 pick. Its published minimum is $50,000, and qualifying accounts may get custodian and storage fees covered for up to 10 years.
Get Free Gold IRA KitStarting With Less Than $50,000?
Noble Gold Investments is our pick for smaller accounts, with a reported $20,000 IRA minimum and one flat annual fee that includes segregated storage.
Get Noble Gold's Free KitFrequently Asked Questions
Which Gold IRA Companies Have Been Sued by the CFTC?
Major CFTC cases include Red Rock Secured, Safeguard Metals, Regal Assets, TMTE (Metals.com) and First State Depository/Argent Asset Group, among others.
What Is the Most Common Gold IRA Scam?
Selling overpriced coins, often proof or proprietary coins, to retirees who move retirement savings into a self-directed IRA, while understating the markup.
How Do I Report a Gold IRA Scam?
Report it to the CFTC, your state securities regulator, your state attorney general and the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center.
Are Gold IRAs Themselves a Scam?
No. Gold IRAs are legal, IRS-recognized accounts. The fraud cases involve specific dealers' sales practices and pricing.
Sources
- CFTC/FINRA/NASAA: Warning to retirees about precious metals fraud
- CFTC Release 8898-24: Red Rock Secured ordered to pay over $56 million
- CFTC complaint: Red Rock Secured (PDF)
- CFTC Release 8812-23: Safeguard Metals consent order
- CFTC Release 9139-25: Safeguard Metals final judgment
- CFTC Release 9001-24: Regal Assets ordered to pay $49M
- CFTC Release 8254-20: TMTE/Metals.com charged
- Texas State Securities Board: Actions against Metals.com
- CFTC: Commissioner Johnson statement on First State Depository and Argent Asset Group
- New York Attorney General: $6 million from Lear Capital
- Texas State Securities Board: Lear Capital bankruptcy settlement
- Gold Alliance closure notice
Choose a Gold IRA Company That Publishes Its Terms
Request the free information kits and compare them side by side. There is no cost or obligation.